Skip to content

Maximizing Value in LDC Merger and Consolidation

While LDC consolidation has generally been seen as a beneficial trend in Ontario’s energy sector, there is evidence indicating that it may not always work optimally for all Ontarians. This post is not going to delve into the cases for or against merger, but rather focus on what can be done to ensure maximum value and success is realized.

I have spent a good amount of my career focused on M&A due diligence and integration and many best practices I have learned from past mergers apply in the LDC world too. There are however some additional challenges given the regulatory environment and unique cultures inherent to LDCs. Here are some key lessons learned and considerations to factor in:

  1. Clear Objectives and Vision: Establishing clear objectives and a shared vision for the merged entity is crucial. This is a best practice for any merger, but the objectives should align with the interests of ALL stakeholders especially given the public nature and critical services an LDC provides. Defining a clear vision helps guide decision-making, facilitates communication, and ensures alignment among all parties involved on the path and end goals.
  2. Stakeholder Engagement and Communication: Engaging stakeholders including employees, customers, regulators, local communities, and other industry stakeholders throughout any merger process is essential. This includes open and transparent communication about the rationale for the merger, potential impacts, stages of the process, and what to expect for future plans builds trust, manages expectations, and minimizes resistance to change. Special attention should be given to engaging with the LDCs’ shareholders and ensuring they are aligned and understand all aspects so they can communicate on your behalf in public forums and are completely aligned around messaging and info.
  3. Dedicated Focus: M&A is time consuming and in my experience the most successful mergers have a dedicated resource on the team whose sole job is to manage the project. This means removing a person from their day job on a temporary basis or bringing someone in from an external partner. Having someone managing planning, stakeholders, legal, due diligence, communication, integration, and all other aspects and who is accountable is key to achieving success and realizing value.
  4. Due Diligence: Comprehensive due diligence is critical before initiating a merger. This involves assessing financials, operations, assets, liabilities, regulatory obligations, and potential risks. Understanding the strengths, weaknesses, and synergies of each organization allows for informed decision-making and integration planning. This is where I see great weakness in most acquisitions. Each side has motivations during the process and often things get hidden or overlooked on purpose because of the timing, goals or resources of a given side. While this may move a merger along quicker, it will eventually come to light post merger causing more headaches. Having a detailed plan and assessment grid and aligned transparency on all sides if critical.
  5. Cultural Integration and Change Management: Recognizing and addressing differences in organizational cultures, work practices, and employee expectations helps create a unified and collaborative environment. Change management strategies that prioritize employee engagement, communication, and training support a smooth transition will mitigate resistance to change. Pay special attention to compensation practices and alignment.
  6. Election and Council Timing: LDCs are generally owned by local government entities such as a municipal shareholder. Special care should be given to ensuring a merger process is started early into a council’s 4 year mandate to ensure deals close during that council’s term. If things progress into another election cycle, it could place all the work at risk as well as the merger itself depending on changing views from a new council or the public.
  7. Regulatory Compliance and Oversight: Adhering to regulatory requirements and engaging effectively with regulatory bodies is essential. Proactive communication with regulators ensures a clear understanding of the merger’s implications and helps navigate the regulatory landscape.
  8. Operational Efficiencies and Synergies: Identifying and realizing operational efficiencies and synergies is a key driver for LDC mergers. Streamlining processes, leveraging shared resources, and adopting best practices enhance the merged entity’s operational performance. Careful integration planning and continuous improvement efforts contribute to achieving these efficiencies. Not to spoil the fun though, what is true of most acquisition in any industry is that they never realize the synergies they anticipated.
  9. Customer Focus and Service Continuity: Maintaining a customer-centric approach throughout the merger process is vital. Ensuring uninterrupted service, clear communication with customers (and council), and responsiveness to their needs will help build customer trust. Implementing customer service enhancements and innovative solutions further enhances the customer experience.
  10. Ongoing Monitoring and Evaluation: Continuous monitoring and evaluation of the merged entity’s performance is essential. This includes assessing financial performance, operational efficiency, customer satisfaction, and regulatory compliance. Regular reviews enable course correction, identifying areas for improvement, and ensure that the merger’s intended synergies are realized (or not).

My experience tells me most acquisitions don’t achieve the benefits anticipated, but this doesn’t mean mergers should be avoided. They still offer value in sharing resources, access to new products or markets, scale and volume benefits, and positive brand impacts, amongst other things. The LDC environment is no different and if anything, LDC consolidation has shown relatively positive synergistic impacts, albeit not always as strong of shareholder value returns as anticipated in some cases. The most important thing is to have a strong plan for all aspects of the merger and to work with people (internal or external) who can focus on making the merger integration successful. The last thing you want is 5 years after merger to be sitting in a position where only your name has changed and little else because at that point change becomes far more difficult. Future LDC mergers in Ontario can be better planned and executed, maximizing the benefits for customers, stakeholders, and the energy sector as a whole.

-Ron Laidman, P.Eng., MBA, C.Dir.

Visit Enertia’s website for more info on how we can help with your growth and diversification strategy: